Open Accessibility Menu

Insurances We Accept

Butler Health System participates in most insurance plans, including Highmark and UPMC health plans, most Medicare Advantage and health maintenance organizations (HMOs). Please refer to the list below. For additional questions, contact BHS at 724.283.6666.

Insurance Plans Accepted

Medicare Products

  • Aetna Advantage
  • Gateway Health Medicare Assured
  • Health America Advantra Plans
  • Highmark Community Blue Medicare HMO
  • Highmark Freedom Blue
  • Highmark Security Blue
  • UPMC for Life
  • Amerihealth Caritas Medicare
  • Unitedhealthcare Medicare
  • Humana Medicare

Medicaid Products

  • Aetna Better Health (former Health America Coventry Cares)
  • Amerihealth Caritas Medicaid
  • Gateway Health Plan
  • UPMC for YOU
  • Medicaid
  • UnitedHealthcare Community Plan(Medicaid Plan)
  • PA Health&Wellness
  • Value Behavioral Health
  • Community Care Behavioral Health

Commercial Products

  • AARP
  • Aetna PPO/HMO Plans
  • Apostrophe
  • Bankers Life and Casualty
  • Beacon Options (Value Behavioral Health)
  • Champus/Champva
  • Cigna Health Plan
  • Devon
  • First Health
  • Great West Life Assurance
  • Health America/Health Assurance
  • Highmark Connect Blue
  • Highmark HMO/PPO Plans
  • Highmark Community Blue Plan
  • Highmark Federal Employee Program
  • Intergroup
  • Mail Handlers Benefit Plan
  • MultiPlan
  • Private Healthcare Systems
  • Tricare
  • UnitedHealthcare Commercial Plans
  • United Mine Workers
  • UPMC Health Plan

Insurance Plans Not Accepted

  • Bravo Health Plan (Medicare product)
  • UPMC Health Plan (Inside Advantage)
  • UPMC Health Plan (Partner Network)
  • Tricare Prime HMO

If you need to obtain health insurance visit the Health Insurance Exchange website at

Related Articles